Adventures and Mousecapades: A Podcast About Disney

212. Would You Rather...? Disney Movies!

Alicea & Nathan Novak Episode 212

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 19:46

Doors close, choices open. We’re diving headfirst into a cascade of Disney Would You Rather dilemmas that test how we think about mentors, sidekicks, power, and responsibility, all while keeping the fun at full throttle. From Yen Sid’s steady hand to Merlin’s lovable chaos, we explore what good guidance really looks like and why structure vs. spontaneity is a decision you make as much as a personality you have.

We square off on sidekicks—Mushu’s snark and magic versus Pascal’s quiet loyalty—and unpack why conversation, humor, and a little dragon fire can change the course of a hero’s journey. Then it’s tools and power: Mary Poppins’ bottomless carpet bag or the Robin Williams–level whirlwind of a rules-bound genie. We talk constraints, creativity, and why having limits can sharpen the wish you truly want. Add Maui’s hook versus a magic carpet, and we hit the big question: is freedom the ability to go anywhere, or the power to become what the moment needs?

Our map gets bigger with world choices: the neon tech of San Fransokyo or the layered communities of Zootopia. One of us craves invention and labs; the other dreams of social design that celebrates difference. We bring that lens to everyday life with Baymax’s gentle healthcare support versus WALL·E’s eco-minded cleanup—care for the body or care for the planet—and push further into team dynamics: the scrappy resilience of the Resistance or the specialized punch of the Avengers. Fashion even gets strategic with Edna Mode’s tailored clarity against the Fairy Godmother’s high-reach magic. And we end with the ultimate risk call: accept Maleficent’s curse or negotiate Ursula’s contract. Spoiler: we’re reading the fine print and bringing a pen.

Join us, pick your path, and tell us where you land. Subscribe, leave a quick review, and share this episode with the Disney lover in your life—then drop your choices and why. Which dilemma did you agonize over the most?

----
Adventures & Mousecapades is a passion project from Alicea & Nathan Novak - two Seattleites addicted to The Mouse. We are not affiliated with Disney, nor are we travel agents. Opinions are our own.

Instagram, Threads, Facebook, Twitter: @ourmousecapades
OurMousecapades.com
podcast@ourmousecapades.com

Welcome And Format: Would You Rather

Intro

Please stand clear of the doors. Por favor, manténganse alajado. Please stand clear of the doors.

Alicea

Hello everyone. I'm Alicea.

Nathan

And I'm Nathan.

Alicea

Welcome to this week's episode of Adventures and Mouscapades. This week we are doing another Would You Rather? Because it was fun.

Nathan

Yes, I would rather. Let's do it again.

Alicea

All right.

Nathan

Yeah. All right. We are going to look at our category of movies, characters, and lore. Yes. Not more. Lore.

Alicea

La la la la la.

Mentors: Yen Sid Vs. Merlin

Nathan

La la la la la lore. So I'll start off. Alicea. Ooh, this is a good one. Would you rather be mentored by Yen Sid or Merlin? Um let's see.

Alicea

So Yen Sid is from The Sorcerer's Apprentice in Fantasia.

Nathan

Correct.

Alicea

And Merlin is from The Sword and the Stone.

Nathan

Correct.

Alicea

Having seen both of those multiple times, I would actually want to be mentored by Yen Sid because Merlin doesn't really do any mentoring at all. It is Archimedes the Owl who really does the mentoring.

Nathan

Okay.

Alicea

Merlin is kind of very chaotic and flighty and doesn't really teach much of anything.

Nathan

Hmm. I was going to take the opposite. And I will grant you that it's been a hot minute since I've watched that movie. And I didn't remember much about Merlin other than kind of chief chaos energy going on there. Uh I'm going to assume that the owl's part of the package. So like inserting into that universe. I would rather deal with chaos. Yen Sid comes off kind of as a hard ass to me. It just does now. Mickey earned Yen Sid getting a little ticked off.

Alicea

Yes.

Nathan

So like I I un I I get that. However, I I I my gut says go with Merlin. So go with Merlin.

Alicea

I think we don't see enough of Yen Sid. True. At the very end, it his his like um stern whatnot turns a little bit to a little softer. Like he's like, because I think Mickey falls asleep or something, and he's kind of like, oh look at him, you know. So I think we just don't see that side to him.

Nathan

Alright, that's fair. That's fair. Well, there's no real way to know. So

Alicea

this is true.

Nathan

Uh our opinions. Did you know that Yen Sid is Disney spelled backwards?

Alicea

Yeah.

Nathan

Okay. Cool. I did too.

Sidekicks: Mushu Or Pascal

Alicea

Okay. Would you rather have Mushu as a sidekick or Pascal as a sidekick? Wait a minute. Hold on. This says, would you rather sidekick Mushu or Pascal?

Nathan

Well I don't want to kick either of them.

Alicea

Does this mean you are their sidekick or?

Nathan

oh! Yeah. Um is that what we're going? You know what?

Alicea

Reading it as is, yeah. It means we would be their sidekick.

Nathan

Okay. I'm going Mushu no matter whether Mushu is my sidekick or I am Mushu's sidekick. Mushu is from Mulan and is Mulan's sidekick, is the family dragon, if memory serves. It's magical.

Alicea

One of the guardians, yeah.

Nathan

Yeah. So, like, there's that whole thing. Pascal, very cool, can change colors, but also has to at least live in the same universe as Mother Gothel. And no, I I want nothing to do with any of that energy at all.

Alicea

She's gone. Don't worry.

Nathan

Now. I I'm I'm just I'm putting myself in the movie, and as things go in the movie, I I don't want to be anywhere near Mother Mother Gothel. Yes. I mushu's where I'm hanging.

Alicea

I agree. I would go with Mushu for the simple fact that you can actually converse with Mushu.

Nathan

Yes, true. And you have a love of dragons. So dragons, yeah. It's not like this is a surprise to me, at least.

Alicea

And he's snarky and I like it.

Nathan

Yes.

Alicea

Yes.

Unlimited Bag Or Chaotic Genie

Nathan

All right. Alicea, would you rather have Mary Poppins carpet bag or Genie's rules, but Robin Williams level chaos?

Alicea

Genie's rules for what?

Nathan

I don't know. Um, how about this? Would you rather have Mary Poppin' carpet bag where you could basically pull whatever you want out of the bag, or you get the Robin Williams genie.

Alicea

So do I want a Time Lord trans-dimensional bag?

Nathan

A TARDIS baggy or a genie.

Alicea

A genie. I'm gonna go genie.

Nathan

Yeah. I'm gonna go genie, if nothing else, because I really want to hang out with a Robin Williams genie.

Alicea

Yes, that would be fun.

Nathan

That would be a chaos for sure. A hundred percent. And if you really wanted to, you could ask that genie to bring Mary Poppins and her carpet bag along.

Alicea

Yeah. It's just the bag of holding. It doesn't like come preset with stuff in it, does it? It's not it's not like a magic bag where anything you want appears out of it.

Nathan

That's actually where my brain went. Okay. Is you could pull whatever you want out of the bag. And therefore, it's similar to a genie, whereas with the genie, you only get three wishes, but you get Robin Williams and chaos with it. So like that's pretty awesome.

Alicea

Okay. Next.

Where To Live: San Fransokyo Or Zootopia

Nathan

Would you rather which one did you say? Are you going you're going genie? Okay. All right. All right, got it. Sorry. I I spaced. Genie, genie. Okay. Genie, genie.

Alicea

Would you rather live in San Fransokyo or Zootopia?

Nathan

Ooh. Okay, so San Fransokyo from Big Hero Six, a very kind of tech forward futuristic city with a ton of really cool gadgets. And you still have uh corporations and evil people. Or Zootopia, where all the animals for the most part get along, although arguably, if all the animals get along, why do you need a police force? And it's basically trying to be a utopia.

Alicea

Zootopia.

Nathan

Right. I'm gonna go Zootopia.

Alicea

Really?

Nathan

Yeah, I'm tempted by San Fransokyo with just the culture and the technology for sure. I think that would be amazing. But the culture of everybody just getting along and all the rest of like Zootopia would be really cool. Like I think younger me would go San Fransokyo and nerd out. I'm gonna go Zootopia. I may have a different opinion tomorrow, but you're asking me today, and my brain says Zootopia.

Alicea

I'm I'm gonna go San Fransokyo.

Nathan

Okay.

Alicea

Personally. I the whole tech thing, I think it's really cool.

Nathan

Um you and your little personal EMP bubble would fry everything and nothing would work.

Alicea

Yeah, that's true. I don't care. I love big hero six. I love just the the city looks so cool. It I'm not really a city person, but I think I would like that more than Zootopia. That's just me.

Nathan

That's her. I mean, it's Zootopia does have like suburbs. I mean, that's where the bunny family lives.

Alicea

And yeah.

Nathan

But look, there's no wrong answers here.

Alicea

No. This is my current preference.

Nathan

Okay. Sounds good. Speaking of, would you rather have Baymax as a healthcare companion or Wall-E as an eco assistant?

Alicea

Oh, this is fun.

Nathan

Um This is a good question.

Helpers: Baymax Vs. WALL·E

Alicea

So Baymax from Big Hero 6 as a healthcare companion. He could scan me if I'm not feeling great and let me know. Here's what you need. Or Wall-E from Wall-E as an eco assistant. What exactly is an eco assistant?

Nathan

He cleans up after you.

Alicea

Yeah. I I think I would rather have Baymax as a healthcare companion.

Nathan

Especially because I have Wall-E tattooed on my arm, and Wall-E’s always with you.

Alicea

Wall-E’s always

Nathan

Well, it's always with me, technically.

Alicea

But No, I just I I I think I think we'd end up getting more use out of Baymax.

Nathan

Especially me.

Alicea

Uh yeah.

Nathan

I mean, he's also kind of fun to have around in general, too. Like he can do other things, but his primary goal is to, you know, fix you, and I need a lot of fixing. Yeah, Baymax. Uh, as much as I actually literally do have Wall-E tattooed on my arm.

Alicea

Yeah.

Nathan

Uh Baymax.

Alicea

That's just because it's a couples tattoo.

Nathan

Yes, it is. I have Wall-E on my arm. Alicea has Eve. They look at each other from the scene where they're flying through out of space when uh we hold hands.

Alicea

We're so cute.

Nathan

Because we're Disney nerd adults.

Alicea

All right. Would you rather join the Resistance or the Avengers?

Nathan

Oh. Oh. Hmm. Um. Well, I was about to say everybody, at least in the Avengers, survives.

Alicea

Uh, no

Nathan

you do have superpowers that way.

Alicea

Um, no.

Nathan

What do you mean no?

Alicea

Does Hawkeye have superpowers? Have you seen him? Does Tony Stark have superpowers?

Teams: Resistance Or Avengers

Nathan

Super capabilities.

Alicea

Black Widow does Natasha have superpowers?

Nathan

Yeah. Have you seen her fight?

Alicea

That's not a superpower.

Nathan

Okay, super capabilities.

Alicea

Okay.

Nathan

Yeah. Um, whereas with the resistance, you're you're just likely gonna be cannon fodder. Um

Alicea

Wow.

Nathan

Yeah. Um but outer space.

Alicea

We could do that with the Avengers too.

Nathan

I was just gonna say that. I have been a Star Wars kid for far, far longer than I have been a uh a Marvel cinematic universe fan. I'm gonna join the resistance.

Alicea

I think I have better survival capabilities if I am with the Avengers.

Nathan

That's that's fair. That's fair. I I I don't disagree.

Alicea

I I don't know that I'd want to necessarily be in a world with the first order and the empire to fight.

Nathan

Thus leave the cannon fodder comment.

Alicea

Yeah,

Nathan

I I get that. I get that. Um although if you're joining the resistance versus the Avengers, is this like you're some lowly person who's probably gonna get a blaster to the chest or versus like a main character in Star Wars who's with the resistance?

Alicea

Oh, I don't know.

Nathan

Like, are you a Jedi or are you in the uh in the Avengers? Hmm. Hmm.

Alicea

Avengers. Okay. It's also current technology stuff.

Nathan

That's fair.

Alicea

Or newer technology stuff. It is not a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.

Nathan

No. Very true. Very true. Yeah, I ha I'm debating now. Okay, it it would be I may have a much shorter life, but I like the Star Wars universe.

Alicea

That's fine.

Style Power: Edna Mode Or Fairy Godmother

Nathan

All right, fair enough. Ooh, okay, Alicea, this is a good one for you. Would you rather have an Edna mode style consultant or a fashion deal with the fairy godmother? Capes are negotiable.

Alicea

Okay, so for this, this is just this is a style consult versus a fashion deal. So a one-time thing versus maybe a fashion line type thing, because that's what it sounds like with a fashion deal. And as much as I really love Edna Mode, and I do, I think having a fashion deal with the fairy godmother would be more lucrative.

Nathan

Lucrative. Wow. Wow. Okay. Your color palette's gonna be fairly limited with the fairy godmother.

Alicea

Why?

Nathan

It's only gonna be pink or blue.

Alicea

Uh wrong.

Nathan

Wrong movie. Yeah. Never mind.

Alicea

Fairy godmother is not Flora, Fauna, or Merryweather.

Nathan

No, I realized that right after it fell out of my face. Um I'm gonna go into the Edna mode universe if for no other reason than I really love the soundtrack. Okay. And I don't need a cape. It's fine. Yeah. Yeah. I'm I'm going with Edna.

Alicea

Okay.

Nathan

Darling.

Alicea

Darling.

Nathan

Yes.

Alicea

That's Cruella. And Edna.

Nathan

Yes, and Edma. Okay. Edma? Edna.

Alicea

I didn't say Edma.

Nathan

I did. It fell out of my face. I have weird things falling out of my face.

Alicea

Wow.

Nathan

They're called words. They're just mispronuncified.

Alicea

Is this wicked?

Nathan

Maybe.

Alicea

Pronuncify. All right.

Nathan

I did grow up in New England. Yes. It was wicked awesome.

Alicea

Would you rather ride magic carpet or wield Maui's hook responsibly?

Nathan

Um, I'd rather wield Maui's hook. I could fly if I wanted to. I could swim. I could kind of turn into whatever the heck I wanted to, as long as my hook wasn't broken and I remembered how to use it correctly.

Alicea

Sharkhead.

Nathan

Yeah. I'm I'm going I'm going Maui.

Alicea

Yeah, I I agree because you could change into any animal that you wanted to. So you could do the flying, you could do the swimming, whatever. I agree.

Nathan

Yep. Cool. All right, Alicea. This one is difficult. Would you rather be cursed by Maleficent or make a deal with Ursula?

Alicea

Ooh. Uh for me this is quite easy.

Nathan

Really?

Alicea

Because if you are cursed by Maleficent, you have no say in it at all. It's just whatever she comes up with.

Nathan

Oh.

Risk Management: Maleficent Curse Or Ursula Deal

Alicea

If you make a deal with Ursula, you are making a deal. There's a contract involved. You can read through that contract and make changes if you're going to make a deal.

Nathan

You're assuming that she's going to allow changes.

Alicea

I don't have to sign it then.

Nathan

Okay. You're going to play hard to get. Yeah. Yeah. That scroll may be miles long, but you're going to read every single last bit of it.

Alicea

If I'm dealing with the Sea Witch, definitely.

Nathan

Okay. Yeah. I actually like that perspective. I think you got that one right. Lawyers are important. And we can read through some legalese and figure it out.

Alicea

Yes.

Nathan

Uh yeah. I mean, we may have to give something up. It depends on what the terms of the deal are, but at least we know we're get something that we want.

Alicea

Yeah.

Audience Q&A Invite And Disclaimers

Nathan

Okay. Yep. Done. Maleficent. It maleficent. Ursula. It is. Ursula. I deal with Ursula. Okay. Rather than being cursed by maleficent. Well, this was fun.

Alicea

Yes.

Nathan

Thank you for uh thank you for playing along.

Alicea

Yeah.

Nathan

I I would ask these questions to our lovely audience listening at home or in the car or at work or wherever you may be. What would you rather do? Who would you rather hang out with? Who would you rather be cursed by?

Alicea

So many things.

Nathan

All of these are interesting questions. Great debate. Let us know in the comments. Send us an email. Drop us a line on socials. You know where to find us. Actually, where do they find us, Alicea?

Alicea

We are at Our Mousecapades on Instagram, Facebook threads, and YouTube.

Nathan

Oh, yeah. And our mousecapades.com. Yeah, that whole place. Just remember, these are our opinions. We're not related to Disney. That would be cool if we were related to Disney, but we're not.

Alicea

We don't work for them either.

How To Connect, Rate, And Share

Nathan

We don't work for them. We're not sponsored by them. No. We're just, you know, making some making some opinions up. Chatting. Yeah, we're just having chat. Uh if you want to, you know, get the official word from Disney, you should go to their website or work with a travel agent. Find your fantastical way to go hang out with Ursula. Yeah. Sounds like a Disney cruise is in order.

Alicea

If you have any questions or would like to chat with us about your own Disney experiences, please send us an email. We are podcast at our mousecapades.com.

Nathan

And of course, please do give us a rating and review in your podcast app that really absolutely 100% helps people find us.

Alicea

And if you want, you can actually share us with some of your friends or family, anybody who loves Disney.

Nathan

Yeah, that's another way people could find us. So I guess it's not 100% how people find us from the ratings and stuff. No, it's just recommendations. That actually is probably more valid. Yeah. So I mean, you know, five-star ratings are great, but they are.

Alicea

We do appreciate them.

Nathan

Send us to your mom. Send us to your friend. Send us to somebody you hate now. Don't

Alicea

say hi to your mom for me.

Nathan

Yes. I see what you did there. All right, y'all. Thanks for listening. We will be in your ears next week.

Intro

Thank you for flying Star Tours. Bye bye.